Practical Living Project

Guess the Grocery Bill

Every so often, I post a picture of my Aldi cart on Facebook and ask friends to guess what I spent. The guesses are all over the place. Some people get remarkably close. Others guess two or three times what I paid.

Now it’s your turn. Look at each cart, make a guess, and then check the answer. These are actual shopping trips from three different years, so you’re guessing what I paid then — not what the same cart would cost today.

Round 1: August 21, 2026

Ylice’s actual Aldi shopping cart
Original shopping photograph

There’s meat, tofu, eggs, dairy, fresh and frozen produce, rice, bread, coffee, and a few treats. Yes, those are Zebra Cakes. Make your guess before peeking.

Made your guess? Reveal the total.

The total: $82.42. Roni guessed $82 — just 42 cents off. Eve guessed $69, then joked that hers was “pre tax.” Other guesses included $120, $150, and $210 “around these parts.” Even the girl at the register guessed double.

Suzzanne had a question about the prize: “What does the winner win? A downloadable ebook on how to shop for less written by you?!”

Round 2: August 7, 2025

Ylice’s actual Aldi shopping cart
Original shopping photograph

Before you guess, there’s something you need to see underneath the cart: a big bag of dog food, a 12-pack of sparkling water, and a 12-pack of cola. Those count toward the checkout total, too.

Ylice’s actual Aldi shopping cart
Original shopping photograph
Ylice’s actual Aldi shopping cart
Original shopping photograph
Made your guess? Reveal the total.

The total: $84.70 for 41 items. Eve guessed $81 this time. Other guesses ranged from $55 to $250. The dog food was $20.99; remove it and its tax, and the food and drinks came to $62.45.

That distinction matters when I talk about my grocery budget. The dogs have to eat, but their dinner doesn’t belong in the figure for feeding two people.

Round 3: June 23, 2024

Ylice’s actual Aldi shopping cart
Original shopping photograph

One more. There’s also a 12-pack of citrus soda that didn’t make it into the photograph. The peaches, tangerines, refried beans, and tortillas are hard to see, too. I’m giving you the same clues I gave my friends.

Made your guess? Reveal the total.

The total: $59.75 for 23 items. Eve guessed $115. Other people guessed much closer to the actual price. The cart included more than 12 pounds of fruit and vegetables, plus 2.2 pounds of beef.

One response after the reveal was: “That’s pretty good! Except there’s nothing to eat.”

Okay. What would you make?

That comment is the interesting part. I see ingredients and possibilities. Someone else sees a cart without dinner.

Take the August 2026 basket. Burgers, buns, and corn could be one dinner. Tofu and mixed vegetables could go with the rice. Eggs, ham, and vegetables could become another meal. Those are possibilities from the purchases, not a record of what I cooked that week. Oil, seasonings, and any sauces would come from what I already had or need to be counted separately.

And I wouldn’t have to use everything immediately. Some meat could go into the freezer. Rice and other pantry items could wait. A bargain bought today might contribute to several meals over the next month.

That’s why guessing one cart correctly doesn’t necessarily explain how my overall grocery spending stays low. The cart is only what I bought on that trip. It doesn’t show the food already in my kitchen, what I froze last week, or what I won’t need to buy next time.

Were you wildly wrong?

A high guess doesn’t mean you’re bad at shopping. You may live somewhere more expensive, buy different brands, or simply not know what those items cost at Aldi. A photograph also hides quantities and package sizes. Heidi changed her guess after I posted the shopping list. Fair enough.

For now, try this with your own next grocery trip: look beyond the total. What meals can you make? What will carry over? What did you buy because it was a good deal — and will you actually use it?

And leave room for something you enjoy. The Zebra Cakes were not an accident.

Keep exploring

New to Practical Living? Start with the grocery bill and follow the thinking behind it.